Matrimonio y orientación sexual: La fuerza expansiva del derecho a la no discriminaciónComentario de las sentencias Taddeucci y Coman

  1. ALICIA RIVAS VAÑÓ
Revista:
Lex social: revista de los derechos sociales

ISSN: 2174-6419

Any de publicació: 2019

Títol de l'exemplar: Homenaje profesor Manuel Terol Becerra, valedor y guardián de los derechos sociales

Volum: 9

Número: 1

Pàgines: 136-161

Tipus: Article

DOI: 10.46661/LEXSOCIAL.3975 DIALNET GOOGLE SCHOLAR lock_openAccés obert editor

Altres publicacions en: Lex social: revista de los derechos sociales

Resum

The evolution of the protection of sexual diversity by the European institutions is indisputable, even if it is still necessary to grant it in relation to rights traditionally not recognized to LGBTI minorities. In this sense, the last jurisprudence of the ECHR and the CJEU give different answers when dealing with such a controversial issue as it is the recognition of same-sex partners, and ultimately, same-sex marriage. This paper tries to analyze the most recent cases leading to such a different interpretation.

Referències bibliogràfiques

  • HODSON, L. NGOs and the Struggle for Human Rights in Europe, Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2011,
  • SMITH, R.A. y HAIDER-MARKEL, D.P. Gay and Lesbian Americans and Political Participation: a Reference Handbook, Santa Barbara: ABC-CLIO, 2002, ADAM, B.D, DUYVENDAK, J.W. y KROUWEL, A. (eds.) The Global Emergence of Gay and Lesbian Politics: National Imprints of a Worldwide Movement, Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1999,
  • ADAM, B.D. The Rise of a Gay and Lesbian Movement, New York: Twayne Publishers, 1995;
  • RAJAGOPAL, B. International Law from Below: Development, Social Movements and Third World Resistance, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003,
  • LOUX, A.C. “Losing the Battle, Winning the War: Litigation Strategy and Pressure Group Organisation in the Era of Incorporation”, King’s Law Journal, vol. 11, nº 1, 2000, pp. 90-104.
  • RIVAS VAÑÓ, A. LGBTI en Europa: la construcción jurídica de la diversidad, Valencia: Tirant lo Blanch, 2019.
  • Annual Review of the Human Rights Situation of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex People, Brussels: ILGA-Europe, 2019;
  • WAALDIJK, K. Extending rights, responsibilities and status to same-sex families: trends across Europe, Consejo de Europa y Ministerio de Asuntos Exteriores de Dinamarca, marzo 2018.
  • HELFER, L. y VOETEN, E. “International Courts as Agents of Legal Change: Evidence from LGBT Rights in Europe”. International Organization, vol. 68, nº 1, 2014, pg. 77-110. doi:10.1017/S0020818313000398
  • HELFER, L.R. “Consensus, Coherence and the European Convention on Human Rights”. Cornell International Law Journal, vol. 26, 1993, pg. 133 ss.
  • SELVANERA, G. “Gays in Private: the Problems with the Privacy Analysis in Furthering Human Rights” Adelaide Law Review, vol. 16, 1994, pg. 331 ss.
  • BAMFORTH, N., MALIK, M. y O’CINNEIDE, C. Discrimination Law: Theory and Context, Text and Materials, Londres: Sweet and Maxwell, 2008.
  • BERTOLINO, R. “La cultura moderna de los derechos y la dignidad del hombre”, Derechos y Libertades, nº7, 1999, pg. 131 ss. 12
  • HENDERSON, L. M., A New Protocol for Equality: A New Vehicle Toward Gay Rights as Human Rights? Mayo, 2010. Accesible en SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1638385 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1638385.
  • SURREL, H. (Dir.) Le Droit à la NonDiscrimination au Sens de la Convention Européenne des Droits de l’Homme, Actes du colloque des 9 et 10 novembre 2007 organisé par l’Institut de Droit Européen des Droits de l’Homme, Faculté de Droit, Université Montpellier, Bruselas: Bruylant Nemesis, 2008;
  • ARNARDÓTTIR, O.M. Equality and NonDiscrimination under the European Convention on Human Rights, The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2002.
  • “The Prohibition of Discrimination under European Human Rights Law”, 2011, pg. 14-21, accesible en https://publications.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/a77beb2e-329b-49a5-88168e45b059802a/language-en, consultado el 12 de marzo de 2019.
  • JOHNSON, P. y FALCETTA, S. “Sexual orientación discrimination and Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights: developing the protection of sexual minorities”, European Law Review, 2018, in print.
  • MARINAI , S. “Recognition in Italy of Same-Sex Marriages Celebrated Abroad: The Importance of a Bottom-up Approach”, European Journal of Legal Studies, vol. 10, 2016-2017, pg. 10 ss.
  • PETERSEN, N. “The Principle of Non-discrimination in the European Convention on Human Rights and in EU Fundamental Rights Law”. En NAKANISHI Y. (eds) Contemporary Issues in Human Rights Law. Singapore: Springer, 2018, pg. 129-142. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-6129-5_7
  • ALONSO OLEA, M. “El Despido de un Transexual”, Actas de la Real Academia de Ciencias Morales y Políticas, 1997, pg. 237 ss.;
  • MARISCAL DE GANTE, M. y LÓPEZ PASARO, E. “Transexualidad y Discriminación”, Revista Española de Derecho del Trabajo, nº 97, 1999, pg. 60 ss.;
  • MORALES ORTEGA, J.M. “Nuevos Fenómenos Discriminatorios: Homosexualidad y Transexualidad”, Relaciones Laborales, nº 18, 1999, pg. 55 ss.;
  • VICENTE PALACIO, M.A. “Transexualidad y Contrato de Trabajo”, Tribuna Social, nº 67, 1996, pg. 55 ss.; BARNARD, C. “P v. S: Kite Flying or a New Constitutional Approach?”, en DASHWOOD, A. y O’LEARY, S., The principle of Equal Treatment in EC Law, Sweet & Maxwell, London, 1997, pg. 59 ss.;
  • VICENTE PALACIO, M.A., “The Principle of Equality in the Community Context: P, Grant, Kalanke and Marshall: Four Uneasy Bedfellows?” Cambridge Law Journal, no. 57, 1998, pg. 352 ss.;
  • LOUX, A.C. “Is He Our Sister? Sex, Gender, and Transsexuals under European Law”, Web Journal of Current Legal Issues, vol. 3, 1997;
  • WINTEMUTE, R. “Recognizing New Kinds of Direct Sex Discrimination: Transsexualism, Sexual Orientation and Dress Code”, Modern Law Review, vol. 60, 1997, en pg. 335 ss.;
  • SKIDMORE, P. “Sex, Gender and Comparators in Employment and Discrimination”, Industrial Law Journal, vol. 26, 1997, pg. 51 ss.
  • BELL, M. “Shifting Conceptions of Sexual Discrimination at the Court of Justice: from P v. S to Grant v. SWT”, European Law Journal, vol. 5, 1999, pg. 63 ss.;
  • BARNARD, C.“Some Are More Equal Than Others: the Decision of the Court of Justice in Grant vs. South-West Trains”, Cambridge Journal of European Law, 1999, pg. 147 ss.;
  • SPACKMAN, P. “Grant vs. South-West Trains: Equality for Same-sex Partners in the European Community”, American University Journal of International Law, nº 12, 1997, pg. 1063 ss.;
  • CONNOR, T. “European Community Discrimination Law: No Right to Equal Treatment in Employment in Respect of Same Sex Partner”, European Law Review, nº 4, 1998, pg. 378 ss.;
  • HELFER, L. “European Court of Justice Decision Regarding Employment Discrimination on the Basis of Sexual Orientation”, American Journal of International Law, vol. 93, nº 1, 1999, pg. 195 ss.;
  • BERTHOU, K. y MASSELO, A.“La CJE et les Couples Homosexuels”, Droit Social, nº 1, 1998, pg. 20 ss. En España SANCHEZ-URAN AZAÑA, Y. “El Principio de No Discriminación Sexual en el Derecho Social Comunitario: ¿Avance Sustancial del Tratado de Ámsterdam?”, en V.V.A.A., Estudios de Derecho del Trabajo y de la Seguridad Social en Homenaje al Profesor Juan Antonio Sagardoy Bengoechea, Madrid: Servicio de Publicaciones de la Facultad de Derecho de la Universidad Complutense, 1999, pg. 363 ss.;
  • WINTEMUTE, R. “In Extending Human Rights, which European Court is Substantively ‘Braver’ and Procedurally ‘Fitter’? The Example of Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Discrimination” in MORANO-FOADI, S. y VICKERS, L. (eds.), Fundamental Rights in the EU: A Matter for Two Courts, Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2015.
  • CHACARTEGUI JÁVEGA, C. Discriminación y Orientación Sexual del Trabajador, Valladolid: Lex Nova, 2001; Ibídem, “La Tutela de la Discriminación por la Orientación Sexual del Trabajador en el Ordenamiento Social Comunitario”, en ASOCIACIÓN ESPAÑOLA DE DERECHO DEL TRABAJO Y DE LA SEGURIDAD SOCIAL, La Igualdad ante la Ley y la No Discriminación en las Relaciones Laborales: XV Congreso Nacional de Derecho del Trabajo y de la Seguridad Social, Madrid: Ministerio de Trabajo y Asuntos Sociales, 2005, pg. 537 ss.;
  • RIVAS VAÑÓ, A. y RODRÍGUEZ-PIÑERO ROYO, M. “Orientación Sexual y Derecho Europeo”, en FERNÁNDEZ LIESA, C. y MARIÑO MENÉNDEZ, F. La Protección de las Personas y Grupos Vulnerables en el Derecho Europeo, Madrid: Ministerio de Asuntos Sociales, 2001, pg. 293 ss.;
  • RIVAS VAÑÓ, A. “La Prohibición de Discriminación por Orientación Sexual en la Directiva 2000/78”, Temas Laborales, nº 59, 2001, pg. 193 ss.;
  • MEENAN, H. (ed), Equality Law for an Enlarged Union: Understanding the Article 13 Directives, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007. 43 Sentencia Tadao Maruko…, op. cit., nº 59.
  • MOLINA NAVARRETE, C. “Diversidad de Orientación Sexual y Principio de Igualdad de Trato Laboral: ¿El Fin de la Diferencia entre Parejas de "Hecho" y de "Derecho"? (Comentario a la Sentencia del Tribunal de Justicia de la Unión Europea, de 12 de diciembre de 2013, asunto nº C-267/12)”, Estudios Financieros. Revista de Trabajo y Seguridad Social, nº 371, 2014, pg. 171 ss.
  • PAPADOPOULOU, G. “Sexual orientation and gender identity law in the European Union and its Court of Justice”, en ZIEGLER, A.R. (ed.) Oxford Handbook of International LBGTI Law-Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity, Gender Expression and Sex Characteristics (SOGIESC) Law from an International-Comparative Perspective, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019;
  • STEHLÍK, V. “The CJEU crossing the Rubicon on the same-sex marriages? Commentary on Coman case”, International and Comparative Law Review, vol. 18, nº 2, 2018, pg. 85 ss. DOI: 10.2478/iclr-2018-0039;
  • STOPPIONI, E. “Une analyse critique de l’arrêt Coman: déconstruction de la consécration de l’obligation de reconnaissance du droit de séjour du conjoint homosexuelË®, European Papers, European Forum, 27 de febrero de 2019, pg. 1 ss. DOI: 10.15166/24998249/280;
  • WAALDIJK, K. “The gender-neutrality of the international right to marry: Same-sex couples may still be excluded from marriage, but their exclusion – and their foreign marriages – must be recognized”, en ZIEGLER, A.R. International LGBTI, forth coming;
  • ÁLVAREZ GONZÁLEZ, S. “¿Matrimonio entre personas del mismo sexo para toda la UE? A propósito de las conclusiones del Abogado General en el asunto Coman”, La Ley Unión Europea, nº 56, 2018. 49
  • GONZÁLEZ VEGA, J. “Buscando en la Caja de Pandora: el Derecho Comunitario ante la Discriminación por Razones de Orientación Sexual”, La Ley-Unión Europea, nº. 4522, 1998. 35 Sentencia Taddeucci…, op. cit., nº 79.
  • GYENEY, L. “Same sex couples’ right to free movement in light of member States’ national identities” Iustum Aequum Salutare, XIV, 2018, pg. 149 ss.
  • HAMILTON, F. “The expanding concept of EU citizenship free movement rights and the potential positive impact this has for same-sex couples relocating across borders”, Famity Law, 2018;