Using the Z-score to analyze the financial soundness of insurance firms

  1. Ignacio Moreno 1
  2. Purificacion Parrado-Martınez 2
  3. Antonio Trujillo-Ponce 1
  1. 1 Universidad Pablo de Olavide, Sevilla
  2. 2 Universidad de Jaén
    info

    Universidad de Jaén

    Jaén, España

    ROR https://ror.org/0122p5f64

Journal:
European journal of management and business economics

ISSN: 2444-8494,  2444-8451

Year of publication: 2022

Volume: 31

Issue: 1

Pages: 22-39

Type: Article

DIALNET GOOGLE SCHOLAR lock_openOpen access editor

More publications in: European journal of management and business economics

Abstract

Purpose – Despite the sophisticated regulatory regime established in Solvency II, analysts should be able to consider other less complex indicators of the soundness of insurers. The Z-score measure, which has traditionally been used as a proxy of individual risk in the banking sector, may be a useful tool when applied in the insurance sector. However, different methods for calculating this indicator have been proposed in the literature. This paper compares six different Z-score approaches to examine which one best fits insurance companies. The authors use a final dataset of 183 firms (1,382 observations) operating in the Spanish insurance sector during the period 2010–2017. Design/methodology/approach – In the first stage, the authors opt for a root mean squared error (RMSE) criterion to evaluate which of the various mean and SD estimates that are used to compute the Z-score best fits the data. In the second stage, the authors estimate and compare the explanatory power of the six Z-score measures that are considered by using an ordinary least squares (OLS) regression model. Finally, the authors report the results of the baseline equation using the system-GMM estimator developed by Arellano and Bover (1995) and Blundell and Bond (1998) for dynamic panel data models. Findings – The authors find that the best formula for calculating the Z-score of insurance firms is the one that combines the current value of the return on assets (ROA) and capitalization with the SD of the returns calculated over the full sample period. Research limitations/implications – The main limitation of the research is that it addresses only the Spanish insurance sector, and consequently, the implications of the findings must be framed in this institutional context. However, the authors think that the results could be extrapolated to other countries. Future research should consider including different countries and analyzing the usefulness of aggregated insurer-level Z-scores for macroprudential monitoring. Practical implications – The Z-score may be a useful early warning indicator for microprudential supervision. In addition to being an indicator of the soundness of insurers simpler than those established in the current regulation, the information provided by this accounting-based

Bibliographic References

  • Alhassan, A.L. and Biekpe, N. (2018), “Competition and risk-taking behaviour in the non-life insurance market in South Africa”, The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance, Vol. 43, pp. 492-519, doi: 10. 1057/s41288-017-0074-z.
  • Altuntas, M. and Rauch, J. (2017), “Concentration and financial stability in the property-liability insurance sector: global evidence”, The Journal of Risk Finance, Vol. 18, pp. 284-302, doi: 10. 1108/JRF-10-2016-0128.
  • Arellano, M. and Bover, O. (1995), “Another look at the instrumental variable estimation of errorcomponents models”, Journal of Econometrics, Vol. 68, pp. 29-51, doi: 10.1016/0304-4076(94) 01642-D.
  • Baselga-Pascual, L., Trujillo-Ponce, A. and Cardone-Riportella, C. (2015), “Factors influencing bank risk in Europe: evidence from the financial crisis”, North American Journal of Economics and Finance, Vol. 34, pp. 138-166, doi: 10.1016/j.najef.2015.08.004.
  • Beck, T. and Laeven, L. (2006), Resolution of Failed Banks by Deposit Insurers: Cross–country Evidence. Policy Research Working Paper 3920, World Bank, WA, DC.
  • Blundell, R. and Bond, S. (1998), “Initial conditions and moment restrictions in dynamic panel data models”, Journal of Econometrics, Vol. 87, pp. 115-143, doi: 10.1016/S0304-4076(98)00009-8.
  • Bongini, P., Iwanicz-Drozdowska, M., Smaga, P. and Witkowski, B. (2018), “In search of a measure of banking sector distress: empirical study of CESEE banking sectors”, Risk Management, Vol. 20, pp. 242-257, doi: 10.1057/s41283-017-0031-y.
  • Boyd, J.H., De Nicolo, G. and Jalal, A.M. (2006), Bank Risk-Taking and Competition Revisited: New Theory and New Evidence, Working Paper 06/297, International Monetary Fund, WA, DC.
  • Caporale, G.M., Cerrato, M. and Zhang, X. (2017), “Analysing the determinants of insolvency risk for general insurance firms in the UK”, Journal of Banking and Finance, Vol. 84, pp. 107-122, doi: 10. 1016/j.jbankfin.2017.07.011.
  • Chen, R. and Wong, K.A. (2004), “The determinants of financial health of Asian insurance companies”, The Journal of Risk and Insurance, Vol. 71, pp. 469-499, doi: 10.1111/j.0022-4367.2004.00099.x.
  • Chiaramonte, L., Croci, E. and Poli, F. (2015), “Should we trust the Z-score? Evidence from the European Banking industry”, Global Finance Journal, Vol. 28, pp. 111-131, doi: 10.1016/j.gfj. 2015.02.002.
  • Chiaramonte, L., Hong, F., Poli, F. and Zhou, M. (2016), “How accurately can Z-score predict bank failure?”, Financial Markets, Institutions and Instruments, Vol. 25, pp. 333-360, doi: 10.1111/ fmii.12077.
  • Cihak, M. (2007), “Systemic loss: a measure of financial stability”, Czech Journal of Economics and Finance, Vol. 57, pp. 5-26.
  • Cihak, M. and Hesse, H. (2010), “Islamic banks and financial stability: an empirical analysis”, Journal of Financial Services Research, Vol. 38, pp. 95-113, doi: 10.1007/s10693-010-0089-0.
  • Cummins, J.D. and Sommer, D.W. (1996), “Capital and risk in property-liability insurance markets”, Journal of Banking and Finance, Vol. 20, pp. 1069-1092, doi: 10.1016/0378-4266(95)00044-5.
  • Cummins, J.D. and Nini, G.P. (2002), “Optimal capital utilization by financial firms: evidence from the property-liability insurance industry”, Journal of Financial Services Research, Vol. 21, pp. 15-53, doi: 10.1023/A:1014369617192.
  • Cummins, J.D., Rubio-Misas, M. and Vencappa, D. (2017), “Competition, efficiency and soundness in European life insurance markets”, Journal of Financial Stability, Vol. 28, pp. 66-78, doi: 10.1016/j. jfs.2016.11.007.
  • Das, U.S., Davies, N. and Podpiera, R. (2003), Insurance and Issues in Financial Soundness, Working Paper WP/03/138, International Monetary Fund, WA, DC.
  • De Haan, L. and Kakes, J. (2010), “Are non-risk based capital requirements for insurance companies binding?”, Journal of Banking and Finance, Vol. 34, pp. 1618-1627, doi: 10.1016/j.jbankfin.2010. 03.008.
  • Delis, M.D. and Staikouras, P.K. (2011), “Supervisory effectiveness and bank risk”, Review of Finance, Vol. 15, pp. 511-543, doi: 10.1093/rof/rfq035.
  • Direccion General de Seguros y Fondos de Pensiones (DGSFP) (2018), Informe 2017 Seguros y Fondos de Pensiones, Ministerio de Industria, Economıa y Competitividad.
  • Eling, M. and Marek, S.D. (2013), “Corporate governance and risk taking: evidence from the U.K. and German insurance markets”, The Journal of Risk and Insurance, Vol. 81, pp. 653-682, doi: 10. 1111/j.1539-6975.2012.01510.x.
  • European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA) (2017), “Insurance statistics”, available at: https://eiopa.europa.eu/Pages/Financial-stability-and-crisis-prevention/InsuranceStatistics.aspx.
  • Fields, L.P., Gupta, M. and Prakash, P. (2012), “Risk taking and performance of public insurers: an international comparison”, The Journal of Risk and Insurance, Vol. 79, pp. 931-962, doi: 10.1111/ j.1539-6975.2012.01479.x.
  • Gaganis, C., Hasan, I., Papadimitri, P. and Tasiou, M. (2019), “National culture and risk-taking: evidence from the insurance industry”, Journal of Business Research, Vol. 97, pp. 104-116, doi: 10.1016/j.jbusres.2018.12.037.
  • Grundl, H., Dong, M.I. and Gal, J. (2016), € “The evolution of insurer portfolio investment strategies for long-term investing”, OECD Journal: Financial Market Trends, Vol. 1, pp. 1-55, doi: 10.1787/fmt2016-5jln3rh7qf46.
  • Haiss, P. and Sumegi, K. (2008), € “The relationship between insurance and economic growth in Europe: a theoretical and empirical analysis”, Empirica, Vol. 35, pp. 405-431, doi: 10.1007/s10663-008- 9075-2.
  • Hannan, T.H. and Hanweck, G.A. (1988), “Bank insolvency and the market for large certificates of deposit”, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol. 20, pp. 203-211, doi: 10.2307/1992111.
  • Hesse, H. and Cihak, M. (2007), Cooperative Banks and Financial Stability, Working Paper 07/2, International Monetary Fund, WA, DC.
  • Ho, C.-L., Lai, G.C. and Lee, J.-P. (2013), “Organizational structure, board composition, and risk taking in the U.S. Property casualty insurance industry”, The Journal of Risk and Insurance, Vol. 80, pp. 169-203, doi: 10.1111/j.1539-6975.2012.01464.x.
  • Hu, J.-L. and Yu, H.-E. (2014), “Risk management in life insurance companies: evidence from Taiwan”, North American Journal of Economics and Finance, Vol. 29, pp. 185-199, doi: 10.1016/j.najef. 2014.06.012.
  • International Monetary Fund (IMF) (2017), Spain Financial Sector Assessment Program Technical Note- Insurance Sector Supervision and Regulation, Country Report 17/338, International Monetary Fund, WA, DC.
  • Khan, M.S., Scheule, H. and Wu, E. (2017), “Funding liquidity and bank risk taking”, Journal of Banking and Finance, Vol. 82, pp. 203-216, doi: 10.1016/j.jbankfin.2016.09.005.
  • Laeven, L. and Levine, R. (2009), “Bank governance, regulation and risk taking”, Journal of Financial Economics, Vol. 93, pp. 259-275, doi: 10.1016/j.jfineco.2008.09.003.
  • Laeven, L. and Majnoni, G. (2003), “Loan loss provisioning and economic slowdowns: too much, too late?”, Journal of Financial Intermediation, Vol. 12, pp. 178-197, doi: 10.1016/S1042-9573(03) 00016-0.
  • Lepetit, L. and Strobel, F. (2013), “Bank insolvency risk and time-varying Z-score measures”, Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money, Vol. 25, pp. 73-87, doi: 10.1016/j. intfin.2013.01.004.
  • Li, X., Tripe, D. and Malone, C. (2017), “Measuring bank risk: an exploration of Z-score”, Social Science Research Network (SSRN), pp. 1-38, doi: 10.2139/ssrn.2823946.
  • Liu, H., Molyneux, P. and Wilson, J.O.S. (2013), “Competition and stability in European banking: a regional analysis”, The Manchester School, Vol. 81, pp. 176-201, doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9957.2011. 02285.x.
  • Maechler, A., Mitra, S. and Worrell, D. (2010), “Decomposing financial risks and vulnerabilities in Eastern Europe”, IMF Economic Review, Vol. 57, pp. 25-60, doi: 10.1057/imfsp.2009.31.
  • Manka€ı, S. and Belgacem, A. (2016), “Interactions between risk taking, capital and reinsurance for property-liability insurance firms”, Journal of Risk and Insurance, Vol. 83, pp. 1007-1043, doi: 10. 1111/jori.12080.
  • MAPFRE Economic Research (2018), “The Spanish insurance market in 2017”, available at https:// www.fundacionmapfre.org/documentacion/publico/i18n/catalogo_imagenes/grupo.cmd? path51098241.
  • Moreno, I., Parrado-Martınez, P. and Trujillo-Ponce, A. (2020), “Economic crisis and determinants of solvency in the insurance sector: new evidence from Spain”, Accounting and Finance, Vol. 60 No. 3, pp. 2965-2994, doi: 10.1111/acfi.12422.
  • Pasiouras, F. and Gaganis, C. (2013), “Regulations and soundness of insurance firms: international evidence”, Journal of Business Research, Vol. 66, pp. 632-642, doi: 10.1016/j.jbusres.2012.09.023.
  • Pavic, T., Miletic, M. and Kozul, R. (2019), “Financial stability of insurance companies in selected CEE countries”, Business System Research, Vol. 10 No. 2, pp. 163-178, doi: 10.2478/bsrj-2019-025.
  • Plantin, G. and Rochet, J.-C. (2007), When Insurers Go Bust: An Economic Analysis of the Role and Design of Prudential Regulation, Princeton University Press, New Jersey, NJ.
  • Rubio-Misas, M. (2020), “Ownership structure and financial stability: evidence from Takaful and conventional insurance firms”, Pacific-Basin Finance Journal, Vol. 62, p. 101355, doi: 10.1016/j. pacfin.2020.101355.
  • Rubio-Misas, M. and Fernandez-Moreno, M. (2017), “Solvency surveillance and financial crisis: evidence from the Spanish insurance industry”, Spanish Journal of Finance and Accounting, Vol. 46, pp. 272-297, doi: 10.1080/02102412.2017.1291167.
  • Rudolph, M.J. (2017), Reviewing Systemic Risk within the Insurance Industry, Society of Actuaries, IL.
  • Schaeck, K., Cihak, M., Maechler, A. and Stolz, S. (2012), “Who disciplines bank managers”, Review of Finance, Vol. 16, pp. 197-243, doi: 10.1093/rof/rfr010.
  • Sharpe, I.G. and Stadnik, A. (2007), “Financial distress in Australian general insurers”, The Journal of Risk and Insurance, Vol. 74, pp. 377-399, doi: 10.1111/j.1539-6975.2007.00217.x.
  • Shim, J. (2011), “Mergers and Acquisitions, diversification and performance in the U.S. propertyliability insurance industry”, Journal of Financial Services Research, Vol. 39, pp. 119-144, doi: 10. 1007/s10693-010-0094-3.
  • Shim, J. (2017), “An investigation of market concentration and financial stability in property-liability insurance industry”, The Journal of Risk and Insurance, Vol. 84, pp. 567-597, doi: 10.1111/ jori.12091.
  • Shiu, Y.M. (2011), “Reinsurance and capital structure: evidence from the United Kingdom non-life insurance industry”, The Journal of Risk and Insurance, Vol. 78, pp. 475-494, doi: 10.1111/j.1539- 6975.2010.01387.x.
  • Strobel, F. (2011), “Bank insolvency risk and Z-score measures with unimodal returns”, Applied Economics Letters, Vol. 18, pp. 1683-1685, doi: 10.1080/13504851.2011.558474.
  • Windmeijer, F. (2005), “A finite sample correction for the variance of linear efficient GMM estimators”, Journal of Econometrics, Vol. 126, pp. 25-51, doi: 10.1016/j.jeconom.2004.02.005.
  • Yeyati, E.L. and Micco, A. (2007), “Concentration and foreign penetration in Latin American banking sectors: impact on competition and risk”, Journal of Banking and Finance, Vol. 31, pp. 1633-1647, doi: 10.1016/j.jbankfin.2006.11.003.
Data source: Dialnet