Civil meanings of child abduction. Analysis of a real case with two partiesSpain (European Union) and Russia Federation
- 1 Universidad Pablo de Olavide, Sevilla
ISSN: 1989-4570
Année de publication: 2024
Volumen: 16
Número: 1
Pages: 886-899
Type: Article
D'autres publications dans: Cuadernos de derecho transnacional
Résumé
There are not many occasions, neither from the investigative point of view nor from forensic practice, much less, as is the case, from both jointly, in which the jurist can study and try to resolve a case of child abduction. The male parent has British nationality; the mother is a national of the Russia Federation. However, it can be said that this history of doctrine and jurisprudence lacked the necessary investigative interest if there had not been a minor, born in Spain, and whom her mother, without the knowledge or consent of her father, transferred to Russia. Thus begins a case that took us to the Court of Justice of the European Union. And, of course, to this research article than shows that between the formulation of a law or rules and its execution, there is always a pervasive chasm that not everybody is able to cross or knows how to do so. Law is more a science of problems than of solutions, and it usually responds poorly -it cannot be otherwise- to facts with a markedly surprising nature.
Références bibliographiques
- G. Palao Moreno. La sustracción internacional de menores en el espacio jurídico europeo, ed. Tirant Lo Blanch, Valencia, 2022
- G. PALAO MORENO y (dir.), M. GONZÁLEZ MARIMÓN (ed. lit.). El nuevo marco europeo en materia matrimonial, responsabilidad parental y sustracción de menores: Comentarios al Reglamento (UE) nº 2019/1111, ed. Tirant Lo Blanch. Valencia, 2022
- A. L. Calvo Caravaca y J. Carrascosa González, online ed.; Sustracción Internacional de Menores: Una visión general
- C. García Revuelta: “Aplicación práctica del Convenio de la Haya y el Reglamento 2201/2003. El papel de la Autoridad Central”, Consejo General del Poder Judicial, 2017
- M. D. Adam Muñoz. “El Convenio entre España y la Unión de Repúblicas Socialistas Soviéticas sobre asistencia judicial”, Poder Judicial, nº 51, 1998
- S. Álvarez González. “El Convenio Internacional de la Haya sobre los aspectos civiles de la sustracción internacional de menores ante el Tribunal Supremo”, en Revista Jurídica española La Ley, núm. 4685, 3 de diciembre, 1998
- Antón, E.A., “The Hague Convention on International Child Abduction.” The International and Comparative Law Quarterly, vol. 30, no. 3, 1981
- M. Montón García: The abduction of minors by their own parents, Valencia, ed. Tirant Lo Blanch, 2003
- S. Álvarez González: Visiting Rights and Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Abduction of Minors: The Spanish practice
- González Vicente: “Sustracción internacional de menores: interpretación del derecho de custodia en el sistema jurídico español: En relación con el Convenio de la Haya de 25 de octubre de 1980”, en Revista Jurídica de Castilla y León, nº 11, 2007
- C. Hamilton and M. Everall, International Child Abduction, Londres, 1994
- I. F. Fletcher, Conflict of Laws and European Community Law; with especial reference to the Community Conventions on Private International Law, Amsterdam, 1982
- S. García Cano: International cooperation between authorities in the framework of the protection of minors in Spanish private international law, 2002
- A. L. Calvo Caravaca y J. Carrascosa González: «Problemas del secuestro internacional de menores», Actualidad Civil, nº 21, 1998
- M. Calvo García: «La protección del menor y sus Derechos», Derechos y Libertades. Revista del Instituto de Bartolomé de las Casas, oct. 1993-marzo 1994
- J. Masson, R. Balley-HARRYS , R. Probert: Principles of Family Law, Sweet & Maxwell, 6ª ed., Londres, 1997
- B. GÓMEZ BENGOECHEA: Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction Problems of Implementation of the Hague Convention of 25 October 1980, Madrid, ed. Dyckinson, 2002
- M. SU-MAMPOU W, Les nouvelles Conventions de La Haye. Leur application par les juges nationaux, t. V, T.M.C. Asser Institut.,1996
- M. E. Sancho Herrera. “Sustracción de menores. Aspectos civiles y penales (1)”, Diario La Ley, núm. 10391, Secc. Trib., 20.11.2023